Traditional Catholic Altars & Church Goods

Sacred furnishings, found and restored for your church.

New and custom-made altars, statues, tabernacles and altar ware. More than 9,000 pieces placed in churches.

Shop the CollectionRequest a Quote
Carved Gothic high altar with saint statues, St. Benedict Catholic Church

Fynders Keepers Brokerage and Church Supply helps churches find, restore, and create beautiful sacred furnishings for their sanctuaries. Based in Stilwell, Kansas, we specialize in custom fabrication and in sourcing new and custom-made Catholic church furnishings for parishes and religious communities across the United States.

From historic church restorations to sanctuary renovations, we work with clergy, architects, and parish leaders to provide altars, tabernacles, statues, candlesticks, sanctuary furniture, and other liturgical furnishings with craftsmanship and care.

Altars

White marble altar with gold Gothic arches, six candlesticks and a crucifix

Statues

Painted statue of the Virgin Mary holding the Child Jesus

Tabernacles

Gilded Gothic tabernacle with a chalice on the door

Stations of the Cross

Painted relief Station of the Cross showing Jesus carrying the cross

Altar Candlesticks

Six tall brass altar candlesticks with white candles

Monstrances

Gold sunburst monstrance

Vestments

Cream and gold embroidered chasubles and vestments

Sanctuary Lamps

Hanging brass sanctuary lamp with a red glass globe

Altar Rails

White marble altar rail with gold Gothic arches

Crucifixes

Dark wood crucifix with a white corpus and gold trim

Baptismals

White marble baptismal font with green inlay and a gold cross

Chalices

Gold chalice set with red stones

Ambos

White marble ambo with a gold cross panel

Tabors

Gilded tabor with two kneeling angels

Seating

Carved wooden church pew with a Gothic end panel

Reliquaries

Ornate gold reliquary

The Exhibition

From the Collection

A closer look at a few pieces from our collection of altars, tabernacles, and sacred vessels.

White high altar with a Lamb of God front panel, candlesticks and poinsettias, below gold relief panels of the Crucifixion

Altars

Notre Dame High Altar

From the complete set of sanctuary furnishings we provided for Notre Dame Catholic Church.

Explore Altars
Gothic brass tabernacle with tall spires and a cross on the door

Tabernacles

Gothic Cathedral Tabernacle

A new European-made tabernacle in polished brass, about 31 inches tall.

Explore Tabernacles
Gold Gothic monstrance with spires and small silver saint figures

Monstrances

Gothic Spired Monstrance

A 23-inch monstrance with Gothic spires and a glass-enclosed luna.

Explore Monstrances
Pair of painted kneeling angels with folded hands and pink-tipped wings

Statues

Adoring Angels

A pair of full-color kneeling angels, 55 inches tall, sold as a set.

Explore Statues
White Gothic antique high altar, removed from a church in Pennsylvania and reinstalled in Bellwood, Nebraska
Bellwood, Nebraska. Antique altars removed from a church in Pennsylvania and reinstalled.

Also on – our antique & pre-owned store

Antique & pre-owned church treasures

Our collection of restored and pre-owned altars, statues and sacred pieces is now available through our eBay store. Here on our website, you'll find new and custom-made church furnishings.

  • 99.7% Positive feedback on eBay
  • 9.7K Items sold on eBay
  • 3,800+ Items available on eBay
Shop our eBay store

Opens ebay.com in a new tab. eBay figures as shown on our eBay store, October 2026.

Testimonials

What Pastors Say

The beauty of the finished altar is amazing. The work of the carpenter is impressive.

Rev. Jan A. ZagorskiPrattville, AL

We asked them to make an altar just like it for us, and we are very pleased with the result.

Father VaccaFredonia, KS
Rated 5.0 out of 5 on Google. 1 review

…a magnificent sanctuary lamp that looks like it came straight out of an old European cathedral. Absolutely beautiful.

Michael Sestak · Google review
Read the full review

Fynders Keepers has helped our church acquire some truly incredible liturgical treasures over the years. Most recently, a magnificent sanctuary lamp that looks like it came straight out of an old European cathedral. Absolutely beautiful.

Working with Brendan has been a wonderful experience. He has a genuinely generous heart and goes out of his way to help others find beautiful things for their churches. You can tell he loves what he does.

Highly recommend Fynders Keepers.

Read on Google (opens in a new tab)Leave us a review (opens in a new tab)

Read more testimonials

Trusted by Churches Across the Country

Fynders Keepers Brokerage and Church Supply has helped parishes across the United States locate and restore sacred furnishings for their sanctuaries.

Through our brokerage network and online marketplaces, we have assisted churches in sourcing thousands of liturgical items, including church altars, tabernacles, statues, candlesticks, and sanctuary furnishings.

  • 9,000+ sacred items sold and placed in churches
  • 100% positive customer feedback
  • Trusted by clergy, parish leaders and restoration teams

Our goal is simple: helping churches preserve the beauty and dignity of sacred spaces.
Recognized in Catholic Media

Our work supporting church renovation projects has been recognized in Catholic publications, including:

  • The Leaven – Archdiocese of Kansas City
  • Catholic News Herald
  • Church restoration projects, such as the renovation of St. Patrick’s Church

These projects highlight the craftsmanship and care that go into restoring sacred spaces and furnishing churches with pieces worthy of the liturgy.
Custom Fabrication for Church Interiors

Every church has a unique architectural character. Our custom fabrication services help parishes create liturgical furnishings that complement their sanctuary and reflect the dignity of the sacred liturgy.

We assist with the design and sourcing of:

  • Church altars
  • Tabernacles
  • Pulpits and ambos
  • Paschal candlesticks
  • Religious statues
  • Sanctuary furnishings
  • Custom liturgical pieces

These pieces are crafted to harmonize with the architectural style of each church and serve generations of worshippers.
Buy, Sell, and Trade Sacred Church Furnishings

Fynders Keepers also helps parishes rehome sacred furnishings. Many parishes undergoing renovations or closures have beautiful sacred items that deserve a new home.

Through our brokerage network, we help churches:

  • Locate rare or hard-to-find liturgical items
  • Find new and custom-made statues, tabernacles and altars
  • Sell or rehome sacred items from parish renovations

Antique and pre-owned pieces are offered on our eBay store.

This approach helps preserve the beauty of traditional church furnishings while helping parishes manage renovation budgets.
Supporting Church Renovations

Fynders Keepers frequently works alongside architects, craftsmen, and parish leaders during church renovation projects, including:

Cathedral of St. Peter – Kansas City, Kansas

Fynders Keepers helped source and fabricate a new all-stone altar for the cathedral sanctuary, part of a major liturgical restoration project. The installation was featured in The Leaven, the newspaper of the Archdiocese of Kansas City in Kansas.

St. Patrick’s Church – Kennett Square, Pennsylvania

This historic Gothic church renovation included new sacred furnishings designed to complement the original architecture, including a front altar, reredos with tabernacle, pulpit, and baptismal font.

Sacred Furnishings Brokerage for Parish Renovations

Fynders Keepers regularly helps parishes rehome liturgical furnishings such as statues, tabernacles, candlesticks, and sanctuary pieces during parish renovations or church closures. Antique and pre-owned pieces are offered on our eBay store.

Our goal is always the same: helping churches restore sacred spaces with beauty, reverence, and craftsmanship.

Serving Churches from Stilwell, Kansas
  • Fynders Keepers Brokerage and Church Supply is located in Stilwell, Kansas, and serves churches throughout the United States.
  • Visits are by appointment only.
  • If you are planning a renovation, searching for a sacred item, or looking to rehome church furnishings, we would be glad to assist.
 Shop now